Old Forester 1920

Old Forester 1920
Whisky Old Forester 1920
Country United States
Type Bourbon
Abv 57.5%
Rating 84/100
Reviews of Old Forester 1920
says on March 18, 2021
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 91/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Russetmuscat

General description

oakey taste

Palate

oakey sweet vanilla taste

Finish

long

says on February 12, 2021
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 87/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Mahogany, Henna notes

General description

candy caramel apple nose. creamy butterscotch pudding. earthy finish.

Nose

Caramel apple. vanilla icing. clove or cinnamon.

Palate

butterscotch pudding. vanilla. creamy.

Finish

earthy / woodsy finish. oak trails to the end.

says on December 21, 2020
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 63/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

A barrel proof offering from Brown Foreman. NAS. Lots of heat. Complex, but with some off flavors when you first open the bottle.

Nose

Maraschino cherries, Fudge, stewed apples, cinnamon cloves. A bit of oak and leather. Medium heat.

Palate

Lots of heat. More maraschinos and fudge. Some other fruit like apple and Celestine. Almost reminds me of an old fashioned. For like the first month this had this overpowering off flavor that made it taste like cherry gasoline. Luckily this seems to have mostly dissipated.

Finish

Ooh that burn. Maraschino cherries come through even more prominently, but with some bitterness like 100% cocoa powder.

says on November 23, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 92/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

Higher proof and stings a little, but less than you expect. REALLY like this one

Nose

Caramel, vanilla, cinnamon

Palate

All the nose plus a little chocolate

Finish

Some chocolate in the finish, decent Kentucky hug

says on November 17, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 83/100
Color: Mahogany, Henna notes

General description

Leggy with a mahogany-brown color. The aroma is milder than expected for 115-proof: molasses, toffee, honey. Mild finished mahogany. Brown leaves and an unraked forest. Rye/cinnamon spices; it comes off a little like a mild curry.

I highly recommend letting it sit in the glass for about 10 minutes to let the really heavy fumes waft their way out. With a few droplets, the sugary aromas bloom and the heat drops in the nose significantly. The cherry juice also busts out.

The burn hits you in the first sip, in a big way. The first sip burns the tip of the tongue, behind your bottom teeth, and on the way down, where the very first sip reminded me of bright orange cough syrup.

The second sip is dry finished wood with the sawdust still on it. This is nearly impossible to maintain straight, so adding a little water is a must here. Even with a few drops, the burn is no joke. It's a physical alcoholic burn, not so much a spicy one. These flavors are much more pleasant diluted with a few drops from the Brita.

The finish is straight up tobacco ash, with a spicy cinnamon and almost chili-pepper flake burn. This thing is a beast: it is chock full of flavor but it's quite challenging. It's really no wonder they banned alcohol in the '20s.

says on October 13, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 87/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

Strong rich straight bourbon whiskey.

Adding a couple drops of water really mellowed the alcohol and brought out the caramel, vanilla, and cherry.

Nose

Vanilla, cherry, leather, red apple, spices

Palate

Spicy and rich apple and cherry pie.hot alcohol forward. Chocolate. Oak.

Finish

Oak. Cinnamon.

says on September 24, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 95/100
Color: Tawny

General description

My new favorite bourbon.

says on September 18, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Tawny

General description

N: the proof jumps but can still smell the cherry.
T: still taste the cherry but with pepper.
F: long and spicy but finished like a chocolate stout beer.

Nose

N: the proof jumps but can still smell the cherry.

Palate

T: still taste the cherry but with pepper.

Finish

F: long and spicy but finished like a chocolate porter beer

says on June 14, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 84/100
Color: Old oak

General description

Intense taste. Sweet, caramelized, toffee taste after you get past the spice & tingle. excellent finish.

says on May 13, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 91/100
Color: Burnt umber

General description

an absolute favorite so far, new to the bourbon world have tried a few so far this is awesome pour

says on May 11, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 73/100
Color: Tawny

General description

Strong, good flavor.

says on February 9, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

Nose of vanilla and caramel. Intense mouthfeel with hints of cinnamon and caramel. Finish was robust with an initial spike, and then slowly faded. Overall, a complex and very enjoyable bourbon.

says on January 23, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 82/100
Color: Mahogany, Henna notes

General description

Sour Cherries. Vanilla. Spice.
Oily mouth feel. Toasted oak finish

says on January 18, 2020
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 90/100
Color: Burnt umber

General description

dark cherries, vanilla, very oily, smooth, sweet caramel

says on November 19, 2019
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Burnt umber

General description

more spicy then expected but high proof

Nose

chocolate fruit and Sweet

Palate

nice hot then settled down and good hug. sweet Rick and nuts on the backside

Finish

warm spice and pepper

says on April 20, 2019
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 80/100
Finish strength: Short
Color: Gin clear

General description

Hot but with good flavor

says on April 4, 2019
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 65/100
Color: Amber

General description

initial bite mellows out quickly. Semisweet, dark fruit, smooth, dry finish

says on March 23, 2019
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 84/100
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

A good, strong and smooth bourbon.

says on February 14, 2019
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 100/100
Color: Deep gold

General description

very nice bourbon. worth $60?
not so sure. I still like woodford Reserve at half the price at my liquor store. nice slight bite and burn; (which I enjoy ) just don't know if its worth the bucks I paid

says on January 10, 2019
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 81/100
Color: Tawny

General description

smooth, well balanced bourbon

says on January 4, 2019
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 88/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Tawny

General description

Really good bourbon. Bold flavors of cherry, caramel, molasses and vanilla and rounds out with a long, spicy, leather kick. A must try for sweet-bourbon lovers.

Nose

Big cherry, caramel, molasses, vanilla, sweet (cake batter?)

Palate

Cherry, syrupy mouth feel, full bodied, caramel hard candy, bit of a spicy bite, a little heat

Finish

Wood, leather, char

says on December 27, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 61/100
Color: Gin clear

General description

good flavor, nothing exceptional.

says on December 26, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 90/100
Color: Gin clear

General description

Smooth and filled with a wonderful caramel flavor

says on December 25, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 80/100
Color: Deep gold

General description

sweet and quite spicy with a medium mouthfeel. the spice and abv called for a small cut of water to make it more pleasant.

says on December 23, 2018
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 90/100
Color: Burnished

General description

The one that has most impressed me to date.

Lots going on with this bourbon. Surprisingly smooth at 57% abv. Lots of caramel and appropriate brown sugar sweetness upfront; followed quickly by tobacco, leather, and spice.

Never too astringent (despite the abv), this bourbon is a complex and tasty sipper.

Rich in body and flavor. Unobtrusive sweetness. Complex enough to really savor each sip.

I'm definitely looking forward to picking up more.

says on December 14, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Color: Auburn, Polished Mahogany

General description

smooth. very tasty

says on December 7, 2018
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 90/100
Color: Burnt umber

General description

Very impressive. Surprised.

Nose

Cotton candy, butterscotch.

Palate

Butterscotch, cotton candy, Easter basket. Peeps.

Finish

So nice. The slight burn comes way at the end love this and would recommend it to first time bourboners.

says on November 27, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 93/100
Color: Tawny

General description

My favorite every day sipper. Great complexity.

says on November 6, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Deep gold

General description

smooth, nice caramel flavor

says on October 29, 2018
Would you buy this again? No
Rating: 72/100
Color: Chestnutoloroso sherry

General description

dry caramel finish

says on October 13, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 89/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Deep gold

General description

Smooth even 115 proof

Palate

Sweet brown sugars

Finish

Sweet caramel, Iight oak, and vanilla

says on October 13, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Color: Tawny

General description

slightly sweet with after burn

says on October 10, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 85/100
Color: Brown sherry

General description

Very nice bourbon. Good balance of spice, sweet and vanilla. ABV 57.5%.

says on October 6, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 95/100
Color: Tawny

General description

Sweet, smokey

says on October 5, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 90/100
Color: Mahogany, Henna notes

General description

This is GREAT! I actually feel sorry for other bourbons trying to compete. Hot but smooth. Flavor, flavor, flavor. Chilled water sweetens and opens up the floral notes. This is a go to if Blanton's is unavailable at the same $60 price.

says on September 26, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 97/100
Color: Gin clear

General description

Wow, this is now my favorite bourbon to sip on. outstanding from start to finish.

says on August 31, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 99/100
Color: Chestnutoloroso sherry

General description

neck and neck fighting for my #1 bourbon

says on August 30, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 100/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Mahogany, Henna notes

General description

Currently my favorite Bourbon.

Nose

Dried Fruit, Caramel, Floral

Palate

Salted Caramel, Citrus, Spice, Nutty. Heavy Mouthfeel

Finish

Oak and Spice with a lingering burn

says on May 11, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 90/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Old oak

General description

Old Forester 1920 is (was) my first foray into high ABV bourbon. At 115 proof, it can be had neat, but drops of water help the flavors to come forth. With time and two drops of distilled water, blended flavors are revealed, but four may be too many.
Mash Bill: 72% corn, 18% rye, 10% malted barley.
Tasting Amount: Two shots

Nose

NEAT: All flavors are well blended, none stand out.
TWO DROPS: Floral at first, then clove, and after 10-15 min. almost exclusively vanilla.
FOUR DROPS: Toasted oak and a hint of sweet cherry/almond. With time, sweet toasted graham cracker comes forward.

Palate

NEAT: Nice warming bourbon feel, but few if any discernable flavors beyond the slightest hint of dark fruit.
TWO DROPS: Subtle banana and bitter citrus. Big vanilla and maple syrup shines through the longer the bourbon is left to open.
FOUR DROPS: Clove spice followed by sweet graham crackers dipped in maple syrup. There is cherry there too, but more of an almond cherry flavor. Dark fruits only appear after the bourbon has been left to open.

Finish

Warmth. Little if any lingering flavors regardless of the amount of water added.
The mouth feel is only slightly oily.

says on March 19, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 91/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Tawny

General description

Great job Brown- Forman

Nose

slow to open, then pops

Palate

strong, woody, fires the tastebuds

Finish

strong relaxing fun

says on February 8, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 91/100
Color: Gin clear

General description

91, light nose, rich full bodied, deep not too complex, dark caramel, rich vanilla, unique finish. medium short

says on February 1, 2018
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 92/100
Color: Burnt umber

General description

Appearance: Copper, oily, thick legs.
Nose: Tobacco, leather, sour green apple, maple, chocolate and just a hint of banana
Palate: butterscotch, caramel, dark chocolate, thick mouth coating and oily.
Finish: green Apple, Cinnamon, vanilla, nuts and oak. The finish is like enjoying a fresh slice of homemade apple pie.

says on September 24, 2017
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 100/100
Color: Gin clear

General description

Caramel and it was beautiful. highly highly suggest

says on September 8, 2017
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 72/100
Finish strength: Long
Color: Deep copper

General description

bitty, but will grow on you. Woody and medicinal.

says on April 7, 2017
Would you buy this again? Yes
Rating: 82/100
Color: Tawny

General description

Takes some time to open up. Some mild wood pulp, fresh up front. Some citrus, like bitter orange. Thick mouth feel, short dry finish.

Leave a review

Your email address will not be published.

Describe this whisky in more detail

New reviews are moderated, so they won't be visible directly.

Flavour profile

  • Vanilla
  • Apple
  • Oak
  • Cinnamon
  • Fresh
  • Sugar
  • Spice
  • Caramel
  • Grapefruit
  • Bitter
  • Honey
  • Peanut
  • Green apple
  • Chocolate
  • Pepper
  • Toffee
  • Fruit
  • Dark
  • Leather
  • Anise
  • Manuka
  • Apple pie
  • Nut
  • Sour
  • Light
Show more flavours

Where to buy